Illustrative Demo Property

18 Birchwood Hollow

Fairfield

$1.875M

score 85

Projects proposed from this house's own photos, priced three ways. Tick what you'd actually do — the all-in price updates as you go.

What can I get for…

—

Drag to auto-pick the projects that fit — must-dos first, then best return per dollar.

6 projects$122k–$147kAll-in price$2,009,000$496/sf vs $493 medianFinanced$1,320/moHELOC 8.5%, 15 yrTime~19 wks1 need permits
Resale impact of this scope: moderate — roughly $72,005 of $134,000 by market-wide cost-vs-value data

Built 1968: carry a 10–15% contingency on top of any selected scope — houses this age hide conditions no photo shows.

Set all:

Your timeline

1

Systems & structure first · ~4 wks

Verify and service HVAC system; replace if end-of-life · Verify fireplace functionality and chimney safety · Investigate inspect windows and weatherstripping; if drafty or seal-failed; repair if confirmed

Livable during work
2

Kitchens, baths & core rooms · ~15 wks

Update secondary bathrooms to current standard · Complete basement finish: rec room, flex space, and laundry integration · Refresh kitchen finishes and verify appliance serviceability

Livable during work
Update secondary bathrooms to current standardworth it some DIY$65k–$72k

Seen in the photos: Photos 13, 14, and 15 show two secondary bathrooms with distinctly dated finishes: one features blue subway tile wainscoting, pedestal sink, and original fixtures (appears 1968 or early 1990s); the other has faded damask wallpaper, wood vanity, and aged fixtures. In a house asking $1.875M with a luxury primary suite, these two bathrooms read as severely deferred and will create buyer objection.

Mid-range: Quartz counters, marble or porcelain subway tile, semi-custom vanity, porcelain or natural stone flooring, good sconce lighting, simple hardware. Matches the primary suite aesthetic without premium materials. Recovers ~45% at resale.

resale impact: moderate
Complete basement finish: rec room, flex space, and laundry integrationworth it some DIY$42k–$50k

Seen in the photos: Photos 19 show basement with mechanical/utility area exposed and partially finished adjacent space with exposed ceiling, unfinished concrete floor, and raw framing. The laundry room (photo 20) is functional but understyled. The lower level is usable but reads as incomplete, and the unfinished mechanical zone creates an eyesore. Completing this space adds ~500–700 sq ft of usable living area and eliminates visual clutter.

Mid-range: Smooth drywall ceiling with recessed LED lighting, finished walls with primer/paint, vinyl plank flooring (wood-look), built-in shelving, good task lighting, painted trim. Feels like an extension of the main house. Recovers ~68% in Fairfield County (basement finishes are strong ROI).

resale impact: high
Verify and service HVAC system; replace if end-of-lifemust do$6k–$8k

Seen in the photos: Photos 19 show a basement mechanical room with a modern-looking natural gas furnace, water heater, and ductwork. The assessor records 'Forced hot air, natural gas' heating and 'central' AC. No building permits on file document when this system was installed or last serviced. The condition is unknown; furnace and AC lifespan is 15–20 years. At $1.875M purchase price, HVAC failure in year one is a significant out-of-pocket risk for the buyer.

Mid-range: Furnace and AC replacement (if either is >12 years old). New high-efficiency equipment (AFUE 95+%, SEER2 15+). Includes new ductwork sealing and smart thermostat. Warranty: 10 years parts, 5 years labor.

resale impact: moderate
Refresh kitchen finishes and verify appliance serviceabilityworth it some DIY$4k–$6k

Seen in the photos: Photos 5–7 show a recently renovated kitchen with white cabinetry, quartz island, marble subway backsplash, and high-end stainless appliances (gas range, wine cooler visible). The finishes are current-era and well-executed. However, premium stainless appliances (especially gas range and wine cooler) are high-failure items; with no permit trail, it is unclear when they were installed, whether they are warrantied, or if any are nearing end-of-life. A pre-purchase appliance inspection and any needed replacement ensures buyer does not inherit hidden defects.

Mid-range: Replacement of one appliance (e.g., gas range or wine cooler) with mid-tier stainless equivalent (e.g., Samsung, LG, Bosch range at $2,500–$4,000). Includes installation and haul-away of old unit.

resale impact: moderate
Verify fireplace functionality and chimney safetyworth it$2k–$3k

Seen in the photos: Photos 8 and 9 show a living room with a working fireplace (brick surround, hearth, mantel visible, fire shown in use). No permits or records document chimney maintenance or sweeping. Fireplaces and chimneys require annual inspection (CT Fire Marshal code) and cleaning to prevent creosote buildup and fire risk. A non-functional or unsafe fireplace is a liability and buyer objection.

Mid-range: Inspection, cleaning, and minor repairs (repoint mortar, replace chimney cap, repair damper). Chimney is safe and fully functional after repairs.

resale impact: high
Investigate inspect windows and weatherstripping; if drafty or seal-failed; repair if confirmedworth it some DIY$4k–$8k

Seen in the photos: Photos throughout show white double-pane windows installed across the house (likely from the 2015–2020 renovation period). Windows appear clean, modern, and well-maintained. However, no permits document their age or warranty. Over time, double-pane windows fail (seal breaks, condensation between panes) and weatherstripping degrades. A pre-purchase window inspection verifies condition and identifies any failures before purchase.

Mid-range: Replacement of 4–8 windows showing seal failure or significant air leakage. Standard vinyl double-pane windows (Andersen, Pella, Marvin). Includes removal of old frame, installation of new window, and caulking.

resale impact: moderate

What order to do it in

Proceed in phases: (1) Systems and structure first. HVAC verification and service, fireplace inspection, window condition assessment. These establish the mechanical foundation and safety baseline. (2) Second priority: bathroom updates and basement finish. basement finish adds usable square footage and eliminates visual clutter. Do bathrooms before basement so plumbing/electrical rough-ins can be coordinated. (3) Kitchen refresh is lowest priority. the kitchen is recent and functional, but appliance inspection ensures no hidden failures. Do this after baths/basement to maintain kitchen access during other construction. Permit all work requiring them (bathrooms, basement drywall/electrical, HVAC replacement if needed) before starting. Bathroom and basement work can overlap if contractor has sufficient crews. Total timeline: 12–16 weeks if all projects run. can be compressed to 8–10 weeks if done in parallel. The secondary bathrooms read dated but functional. Bringing them current is estimated at $55k–$75k; because they work, this is treated as modernization rather than required repair and is not deducted from value.

See what affects the offer